I can't stop listening to this record. I have no idea if it'll stand up to the test of time, but I know that after almost ten times through (it's only been out a week) I am nowhere close to bored of it.
I have two more things to say about the record. First, my friend Robbie recommended it to me and he deserves some credit. Second, they remind me of Wilco even though they very little like them. On top of being talented musicians and songwriters, Arcade Fire have a very adventurous spirit, which is why I associate them with Wilco.
It's been a short year, but here is my best of 2004 (up until now):
1. Air - Talkie Walkie
These two fine gents have gotten back on the horse after a few mishaps (Barrico, 10,000 MHz Legend). Many of the critics claim that this is their best record since Moon Safari, but I would say it's their best ever.
Air's sound is not radically different and they didn't add some amazing new producer for the new record. In fact, they produced it themselves after working with the producer of Beck's Midnight Vultures on 10,000 MHz Legend. The bottom line is that Talkie Walkie is just a completely solid outting. The record is cohesive, which is important to me, but still manages to have a number of songs that can stand well on their own. My favorites thus far are "Cherry Blossom Girl," "Run," and "Alpha Beta Gamma."
If you've heard Air, you probably know whether or not you like them. If you're a fan, run out and get this record. If not, there is not much here that might sway you.