After putting together Simply Structured and years of hearing people gripe about the dearth of style in feed readers, I've realized my biggest request for NetNewsWire, or any reader for that matter, is customized styles for each feed. Even more, I don't just want the end-user to be able to customize styles, but for the author to be able to push styles alongside their content.
Styles on a feed-by-feed basis isn't a huge stretch, especially in NNW where style packages already exist, but pushing styles with your feed is something RSS and Atom don't support. But so what? In the early days of HTML, Netscape Navigator went beyond the HTML spec and added unsupported styles that developers wanted and the web is a better place for it. I'm not advocating for every feed reader to require its own custom flavor of RSS, but if they could add one line that was easily ignored by other RSS parsers, it would make for a fantastic experience. If we're already designing custom versions of sites for our iPhones and other mobile platforms, why not feed readers too?
You could argue custom styles unnecessarily complicate a feed reader, but I don't think it effects how most people consume feeds. The primary benefit of feed readers is having a device that notifies you when there is new content. The second largest benefit is having all the content in one place. Individual styles don't diminish these facts and help bring some individuality back to the web. In a time when we all have custom homepages and visit fewer and fewer sites, it'd be nice to inject a bit more personality into our daily lives.
01/24/08 3:57 PM
No no no no!
Half the reason I got into RSS feeds was so I could stop having to have every single damn page I visit inundate me with their idea of what they think a website should look like! Black on white, white on black, green on polka dot, ugly borders and fonts and shit. I want content.
Imagine if I changed the channel on my digital cable box, and switching to VH1 would show the channel number in a retro 90s font, Nick would have the channel number in a font with a GACK splat, MSNBC would use a courier new, Animal Planet had a crocodile in the shape of the channel number...
See, now I have one CSS stylesheet for my feed reading, and everything comes out the way I want it: legible, clean, and not-standing-out-as-a-productivity-wasting-site-while-I'm-at-work.
Although, I assume if someone made a feature like that, I could easily shut it off. So power to customization.
01/27/08 11:09 AM
I think this is a fabulous idea - though, as Gil said, hopefully you will be able to turn it off if necessary.
01/31/08 4:19 PM
So then people keep pushing 10px text onto my screen [like this website]? No thanks!